IHT and Dividend Waivers: When Waiving a Dividend Is a Transfer of Value
A dividend waiver may be a transfer of value under s3 IHTA 1984 — reducing the waiving shareholder's estate and potentially conferring a gratuitous benefit on connected shareholders. Section 10 IHTA 1984 can exempt genuinely commercial waivers, but HMRC scrutinises dividend waivers in family companies closely. Where the benefit flows to a family member, the waiver is likely a PET subject to the 7-year clock.
IHT Analysis: Step by Step
1. Is there a disposition?
A dividend waiver is a voluntary act by a shareholder to give up their entitlement to a dividend that has been declared by the company. This is a 'disposition' within s272 IHTA 1984 — an act by which the value of a person's estate is reduced. The shareholder's estate is reduced by the amount of the dividend waived.
2. Does the disposition reduce the estate? (s3 IHTA 1984)
A disposition is a transfer of value if it reduces the value of the disposer's estate and the reduction is not matched by consideration received. A shareholder who waives a dividend receives nothing in return — so the waiver reduces the estate by the amount of the forgone dividend. Prima facie, it is a transfer of value.
3. Is it exempt under s10 IHTA 1984?
Section 10 IHTA 1984 provides that a disposition is not a transfer of value if it was not intended to confer a gratuitous benefit AND was made at arm's length between unconnected parties (or, if between connected parties, was such as might be expected to be made in an arm's-length transaction between unconnected parties). Where the waiver is purely commercial — e.g. the shareholder waives dividends to preserve the company's cashflow with no intention of benefiting connected shareholders — s10 may apply. But where the waiver effectively redirects dividend income to other connected shareholders (e.g. a spouse or children), HMRC is likely to treat this as conferring a gratuitous benefit on those other shareholders, and s10 will not apply.
4. Who benefits from the waiver?
The key question for IHT is: who gets the money that the waiving shareholder gave up? Where the waived dividend stays in the company (increasing retained earnings), the company's value rises — which may benefit all shareholders pro-rata. But where the company subsequently pays dividends to other shareholders using the retained earnings, the benefit effectively flows to them. In a family company where the waiving shareholder's spouse or adult children hold shares, HMRC will look at whether the waiver was structured to benefit them at the waiving shareholder's expense. If so, the waiver is a transfer of value — and potentially a PET to the connected shareholders — not an exempt commercial transaction.
5. What is the quantum of the transfer?
If the waiver is a transfer of value, the amount is the value of the waived dividend — i.e. the cash the shareholder would have received if they had not waived. If the waived dividend then accumulates in the company and increases the value of shares held by connected persons, HMRC may also look at whether there is an additional transfer of value by reference to the increase in share values. This is the 'associated operations' argument (s268 IHTA 1984) — a series of related steps that together constitute a transfer of value even if no single step does.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a dividend waiver and why is it used?
A dividend waiver is a written deed executed by a shareholder before the dividend is paid (it must be executed before the right to the dividend crystallises, not after). The shareholder formally gives up their right to receive the declared dividend. Dividend waivers are most commonly used in family companies to achieve income tax efficiency: if the company can pay dividends to a lower-rate taxpayer (e.g. a spouse with unused basic-rate band) without paying them to a higher-rate taxpayer (e.g. the main working director), the overall family income tax bill falls. However, HMRC challenges both the income tax and IHT consequences of dividend waivers in family companies, and the use of waivers for income redistribution requires careful analysis.
Is a dividend waiver always a transfer of value for IHT?
Not always — but it frequently is in family company contexts. Under s3 IHTA 1984, a disposition is a transfer of value if it reduces the disposer's estate and confers a benefit on someone else. Section 10 IHTA 1984 exempts dispositions that are not intended to confer a gratuitous benefit and are arm's-length commercial transactions. Where a director-shareholder waives dividends to preserve company cashflow for genuine commercial reasons (not to benefit connected shareholders), and the company would have had identical results if the same shareholder had not waived, s10 can exempt the waiver. But where the primary or secondary purpose of the waiver is to redirect income to family members with lower tax rates, HMRC will argue that the waiver confers a gratuitous benefit on the other shareholders — making it a transfer of value and potentially a PET.
What is the IHT treatment if the waiver is a transfer of value?
If the dividend waiver is a transfer of value, it is most likely a potentially exempt transfer (PET) if the benefit passes to another individual (e.g. a spouse or adult child). A PET: (1) is not immediately taxable — no IHT arises at the time of the waiver; (2) becomes chargeable if the waiving shareholder dies within 7 years; (3) is taxed at 40% above the available NRB on the amount transferred (the value of the waived dividend), with taper relief for deaths in years 3–7. If the waiver benefits a trust rather than an individual, it is a CLT — immediately taxable at 20% above the NRB. Where the waiver is part of a series of transactions designed to shift value over multiple years, HMRC may apply the associated operations rules (s268 IHTA 1984) to aggregate them.
How does HMRC approach dividend waivers in family companies?
HMRC's approach (set out in its Inheritance Tax Manual at IHTM04151) is to scrutinise dividend waivers in family companies as potential transfers of value. HMRC looks at: (1) whether the waiver was genuinely commercial (not connected to income tax planning); (2) whether the other shareholders in the company are connected persons (family members) who benefit from the waiver; (3) whether the pattern of waivers over time suggests an arrangement designed to redirect value. HMRC has also relied on the associated operations rules to aggregate a series of waivers with other connected transactions (e.g. an issue of shares to a family member, followed by dividend waivers to redirect income to them). The income tax challenge to waivers (under the settlements legislation in ITTOIA 2005 s625) is separate but often concurrent. Tax advice is essential before using a dividend waiver structure in a family company.
Can the spousal exemption protect a dividend waiver?
If the benefit of the dividend waiver passes to the waiving shareholder's UK-domiciled spouse (because the spouse holds shares and the retained dividend increases the value of their shares, or because the company pays a dividend to the spouse using the retained funds), the spousal IHT exemption (s18 IHTA 1984) may apply — providing the waiver is a transfer of value. The transfer would be exempt from IHT. However, HMRC has argued that the benefit does not pass directly to the spouse — it passes to the company (as retained earnings) and only indirectly to the spouse via their share value. Whether this indirect benefit qualifies for the spousal exemption is fact-specific and contested. Where the benefit is clearly and directly flowing to the spouse's shares, the spousal exemption is a reasonable argument. Where the chain is more indirect, the position is less certain.
Own Shares in a Family Company?
Family company IHT planning — BPR, shareholding structure, dividend policy, and your will — requires specialist advice. A WillSafe will kit ensures your share-related IHT intentions are clearly documented in your estate plan.
View Will Kits from £39.99