Leaving a Legacy to a Club or Unincorporated Association in Your Will
A gift to an unincorporated association (a sports club, residents group, or society with no legal personality) can take effect using the contract-holding analysis from Re Recher [1972] — but fails entirely if the association has dissolved.
How Courts Analyse Gifts to Unincorporated Associations
Contract-holding theory — Re Recher [1972]
ValidThe gift passes to current members as an accretion to the association's funds held under the contract between members. This is the preferred analysis for modern non-charitable clubs. The funds are owned beneficially by members collectively under their mutual contractual rules.
Purpose trust — void
Void / failsA gift 'to advance the purposes of the X Society' is a non-charitable purpose trust — void for want of a beneficiary (Re Denley [1969] is an exception only for defined groups of individuals). Unless the purpose is charitable, a gift expressly for the association's purposes fails.
Gift to present members as joint tenants — Re Denley approach
ValidIf the gift is to the individual members for their personal benefit, it can be valid. But an outright gift to named individuals as joint tenants is not the same as a gift to the association as an institution.
Bona vacantia — dissolved association
Void / failsIf the association had dissolved before the testator's death, the gift lapses and falls into residue. If the association dissolves after the grant of probate, unexpended funds may pass to the Crown as bona vacantia (or to members if the rules provide for distribution).
Frequently Asked Questions
What is an unincorporated association and why is it difficult to leave it a legacy?
An unincorporated association is a group of two or more people joined together for a common purpose under a contract between them — but with no separate legal personality. Common examples include sports clubs, social clubs, residents' associations, political groups, and informal charities that have not incorporated. Because the association has no legal personality, it cannot own property in its own name, enter contracts in its own name, or sue or be sued in its own name. This creates a problem when a will leaves a gift 'to the X Club' — the gift is made to an entity that does not legally exist. Courts have developed several approaches to saving these gifts, but the technical analysis is important because an incorrectly drafted gift can fail entirely.
What is the Re Recher [1972] contract-holding theory?
Re Recher's Will Trusts [1972] Ch 526 (Brightman J) established the analysis that has become the standard approach for gifts to non-charitable unincorporated associations. The gift is treated as passing to the current members of the association as an accretion to the funds held under the contract between members — the association's rulebook or constitution. The money becomes part of the collective fund available to the association under its own rules. This saves the gift from failing as a purpose trust (which would be void) because the members are the real beneficiaries under their contractual arrangement. The gift does not have to be made to 'current members as joint tenants' or use any special wording — an ordinary gift 'to the X Club' is interpreted in this way if the context supports it.
What happens to the gift if the association has dissolved?
If the association had dissolved before the testator's death, the gift lapses — it fails entirely and falls into residue. There is no one to take the gift because the contractual group has ceased to exist. Where the association dissolves after the death but before the legacy is paid, the unexpended funds may pass to the Crown as bona vacantia if the association's rules make no provision for distribution of assets on dissolution. If the rules provide for distribution among members on winding up, the members at the date of dissolution take the assets. The testator's legacy becomes part of the pool. Practically, testators should check whether the association they wish to benefit is actively trading and has clear rules for dissolution.
Can I leave money to a charity that is an unincorporated association?
Yes — a gift to a registered charity that operates as an unincorporated association (rather than a charitable incorporated organisation, a CIO, or a charitable company) is valid as a charitable gift. Charitable gifts are treated differently from non-charitable purpose trusts: cy-pres doctrine allows a failed or impractical charitable gift to be redirected to a similar charitable purpose. The Charities Act 2011 s62 governs cy-pres for initial failure (the charity never existed or dissolved before death) and subsequent failure (the charity dissolved after death). A charitable unincorporated association can also enter into a valid gift trust — its charitable purpose provides the necessary certainty of objects to avoid the purpose trust problem. If you wish to leave to a local charity that is an unincorporated association, include the registered charity number in the will to identify it precisely.
How should I draft a legacy to a club or society in my will?
To maximise the chance that a gift to an unincorporated association takes effect: (1) identify the association precisely — include its full name, any registration number (if applicable), and its address or principal objects; (2) if the association is a registered charity, include the charity registration number; (3) add a saving gift — 'if the [Club] has been dissolved or has ceased to exist before my death, then to [alternative beneficiary]'; (4) consider whether the association might have incorporated (as a company limited by guarantee, a CIO, or an incorporated sports club) by the time of your death — if so, the gift to the incorporated entity should still work but check the new name; (5) check the association's rules for dissolution — if there is a risk that the assets go to bona vacantia on dissolution, consider leaving to the trustees of the association rather than the association itself.
Leave Gifts That Actually Work
A poorly drafted gift to a club or association may fail. WillSafe guides you through legacy gifting with clear, legally sound wording. From £19.97 for England and Wales.