Witness to a Will Who Is Also a Beneficiary: What Happens?
If someone who witnesses your will is also named as a beneficiary, their gift is voided by s15 Wills Act 1837 — but the will itself remains valid. One common mistake destroys a gift that was meant to be given.
The Rule (s15 Wills Act 1837)
A gift in a will to a witness, or to the spouse or civil partner of a witness, is void. The will itself remains valid and the attestation counts. Only the gift to the witness-beneficiary (or their partner) is purged.
What the Rule Does — and Does Not — Affect
Void under s15
- ✗Gift to a witness of the will
- ✗Gift to the spouse of a witness (at time of signing)
- ✗Gift to the civil partner of a witness (at time of signing)
- ✗Any share of residue left to a witness
- ✗Any specific legacy to a witness's spouse
Unaffected — still valid
- ✓The will itself — remains legally valid
- ✓All other gifts to non-witness beneficiaries
- ✓Appointment of executors
- ✓Guardianship provisions
- ✓Funeral wishes
- ✓Trust provisions for other beneficiaries
Worked Example
A will leaves: (1) £10,000 to daughter Amy; (2) the house to son Ben; (3) residue to charity.
Amy signs the will as a witness.
✗ Gift (1) — £10,000 to Amy — is VOID. Falls into residue (to the charity).
✓ Gift (2) — house to Ben — fully valid.
✓ Gift (3) — residue to charity — fully valid (and now includes the £10,000).
The will is valid and admitted to probate — only Amy's gift is lost.
Frequently Asked Questions
What happens if a witness to a will is also a beneficiary under it?
Under s15 Wills Act 1837, a gift in a will to a person who signs the will as a witness (or attests it) — or to the spouse or civil partner of such a witness — is void. The gift fails. However, the will itself remains legally valid and the attestation counts for the purpose of making the will valid. This is described as 'purging' the gift. The witness-beneficiary is not disqualified from acting as a witness — they have validly attested the will. They simply cannot benefit from it under s15. Example: a testator leaves £10,000 to his daughter and then asks her to sign as a witness. The will is valid. But the gift of £10,000 to the daughter is void — it falls into residue (or passes on intestacy if there is no residue provision). The daughter receives nothing.
Does s15 Wills Act 1837 apply to the spouse or civil partner of a witness?
Yes. Section 15 Wills Act 1837 (as amended) expressly extends the purging rule to the spouse or civil partner of a witness at the time of attestation. If a witness's spouse or civil partner is a beneficiary, that beneficiary's gift is also void. Note: it is the relationship at the time of signing the will that matters. If the witness subsequently marries the beneficiary after the will is signed, that does not retrospectively void the gift. Conversely, if the witness and the beneficiary were married at the time of signing and later divorced before the testator's death, the purging rule still applied at the time of attestation — the gift remains void (though a new will or codicil could restore it). The safest rule: never ask anyone who is named as a beneficiary in the will (or whose partner is named) to witness the will.
Does the witness-beneficiary rule void the whole will or just that gift?
Only the gift to the witness-beneficiary (or their spouse/civil partner) is void. The rest of the will — all other gifts, the appointment of executors, guardianship provisions, funeral wishes — remains entirely valid and effective. Example: a will leaves (1) £5,000 to A, (2) the house to B, and (3) the residue to C. A witnesses the will. Result: gift (1) to A is void. Gifts (2) and (3) are entirely unaffected. The void gift falls into the residue (to C) or into intestacy if there is no residue clause. The will is otherwise perfectly valid and can be admitted to probate.
Who can legally witness a will in England and Wales?
Under s9 Wills Act 1837, a will must be signed in the presence of two independent witnesses who each also sign (or acknowledge their signatures) in the presence of the testator. There is no requirement for witnesses to be solicitors, notaries, or any particular profession. Requirements: (1) The witness must be aged 18 or over (or 16 in very limited circumstances); (2) The witness must have mental capacity; (3) The witness must not be blind — a blind person cannot witness a will as they cannot see the testator sign; (4) The witness should not be named as a beneficiary in the will (or be the spouse/civil partner of a beneficiary). People who should NOT witness: a beneficiary or their spouse/civil partner; the executor's spouse if the executor is also a beneficiary; anyone whose ability to understand what they are witnessing is in doubt.
Can the problem be fixed if a beneficiary has already witnessed the will?
Yes — but a new document is needed: (1) New will — the simplest fix. The testator makes a new will, this time ensuring the witnesses are independent. The new will replaces the defective one; (2) Codicil — the testator adds a codicil to the will (a supplementary document) that re-makes the void gift. The codicil must itself be signed and witnessed by two independent witnesses (not the same person whose gift was void). The codicil restores the gift; (3) No action needed if the beneficiary is happy not to receive the gift — if, say, the witness-beneficiary does not wish to receive anything, there is nothing to fix. Once the testator has died, the gift cannot be retrospectively restored. A deed of variation after death can reallocate assets from residuary beneficiaries to the void-gift recipient, but this requires the residuary beneficiaries' consent and may have IHT implications.
Get Your Will Witnesses Right First Time
The WillSafe kit includes a clear witnessing guide so you know exactly who can and cannot witness your will. From £19.97 for England and Wales.